Material is only one variable
Ceramic, plastic and foam can all support nitrification. Accessible area, oxygen transfer and organic coating determine realised capacity.
Aquarium biofilters contain diverse ammonia oxidisers; a product is a habitat, not a sealed packet of one magic organism.
Preserve colonised capacity
Swish clogged media gently in removed tank water. Do not boil, disinfect or allow it to dry. Replace crumbling media by fractions with overlap.
If ammonia follows wholesale replacement, reduce feeding and additions while the remaining system recolonises.